What are the disadvantages of the parallel voting electoral system?

Electoral Systems Questions



80 Short 80 Medium 47 Long Answer Questions Question Index

What are the disadvantages of the parallel voting electoral system?

The parallel voting electoral system has several disadvantages.

1. Fragmentation of political representation: This system often leads to a fragmented political landscape with multiple parties represented in the legislature. This can make it difficult to form stable governments and can result in frequent coalition governments, which may lead to political instability.

2. Limited proportionality: While the parallel voting system aims to combine elements of both proportional representation and plurality systems, it often fails to achieve true proportionality. This can result in a discrepancy between the percentage of votes a party receives and the number of seats it is allocated, leading to a lack of fair representation.

3. Wasted votes: In this system, votes for smaller parties that do not win in the single-member districts are often wasted, as they do not contribute to the overall seat allocation. This can discourage voters from supporting smaller parties and can lead to a concentration of power in larger parties.

4. Strategic voting: The parallel voting system can encourage strategic voting, where voters strategically choose to support a different party in the single-member district to maximize their chances of electing a candidate from their preferred party. This can distort the true preferences of voters and undermine the democratic process.

5. Complexity: The parallel voting system can be complex and difficult for voters to understand, especially when there are different rules for the proportional representation and single-member district components. This complexity can lead to confusion and may discourage voter participation.

Overall, while the parallel voting system has some advantages, such as maintaining a link between constituents and their representatives, it also has significant disadvantages that can undermine the fairness and effectiveness of the electoral process.