How does Scientific Realism address the problem of scientific realism and skepticism?

Philosophy Scientific Realism Questions Medium



30 Short 80 Medium 13 Long Answer Questions Question Index

How does Scientific Realism address the problem of scientific realism and skepticism?

Scientific Realism is a philosophical position that asserts the existence of an external world that is independent of our perceptions and theories, and that scientific theories aim to provide an accurate representation of this world. It holds that scientific theories should be understood as approximately true descriptions of reality, and that the success of science in explaining and predicting phenomena is evidence of the truthfulness of these theories.

In addressing the problem of scientific realism and skepticism, Scientific Realism provides several arguments and responses. Firstly, it argues that the success of science in making accurate predictions and technological advancements is strong evidence for the truthfulness of scientific theories. The fact that scientific theories have consistently been able to explain and predict natural phenomena suggests that they are reliable and provide an accurate understanding of the world.

Secondly, Scientific Realism emphasizes the concept of inference to the best explanation. It argues that scientific theories are the best explanations for the observed phenomena, and therefore, they should be accepted as true or approximately true. This approach acknowledges that scientific theories are not infallible or absolute, but they are the most reasonable and reliable explanations available based on the evidence and observations.

Furthermore, Scientific Realism highlights the concept of scientific progress. It argues that science has made significant advancements over time, refining and improving our understanding of the world. This progress is seen as evidence that scientific theories are getting closer to the truth and that they are not merely subjective or arbitrary constructs.

Scientific Realism also addresses skepticism by acknowledging that scientific theories are fallible and subject to revision. It recognizes that new evidence or observations may require modifications or even the abandonment of existing theories. However, this does not undermine the overall reliability and truthfulness of scientific theories. Instead, it demonstrates the self-correcting nature of science and its commitment to seeking the most accurate understanding of the world.

In conclusion, Scientific Realism addresses the problem of scientific realism and skepticism by emphasizing the success of science in explaining and predicting phenomena, the concept of inference to the best explanation, the notion of scientific progress, and the recognition of fallibility and revision in scientific theories. It provides a robust defense of the reliability and truthfulness of scientific theories while acknowledging the need for ongoing inquiry and refinement.