Discuss the concept of implicature in relation to relevance theory.

Philosophy Pragmatics Questions Medium



19 Short 80 Medium 47 Long Answer Questions Question Index

Discuss the concept of implicature in relation to relevance theory.

Implicature is a concept in pragmatics that refers to the meaning conveyed indirectly or implied by an utterance, beyond its literal or explicit meaning. It was first introduced by philosopher H.P. Grice, who argued that speakers often communicate more than what is explicitly stated, and that listeners are able to infer these additional meanings based on certain conversational principles.

Relevance theory, developed by Dan Sperber and Deirdre Wilson, is a pragmatic framework that focuses on the cognitive processes involved in communication. According to relevance theory, communication is driven by the principle of relevance, which states that speakers aim to provide information that is relevant to the listener's cognitive context.

In relation to relevance theory, implicature plays a crucial role in communication. When a speaker produces an utterance, they do so with the expectation that the listener will be able to infer certain implicatures based on the principle of relevance. These implicatures are not explicitly stated, but are derived by the listener through a process of inference.

Relevance theory suggests that implicatures arise when the listener detects a cognitive effect that is not explained by the literal meaning of the utterance alone. This cognitive effect can be explained by the assumption that the speaker intended to communicate something beyond the explicit meaning, and the listener infers this additional meaning based on the principle of relevance.

For example, if someone says "It's hot in here," the literal meaning is a statement about the temperature. However, the implicature could be that the speaker wants someone to open a window or turn on the air conditioning. The listener infers this implicature based on the relevance of the speaker's statement in the context of the current temperature.

In conclusion, implicature is a concept in pragmatics that relates to the additional meaning conveyed indirectly or implied by an utterance. In relevance theory, implicatures are derived by the listener through a process of inference, based on the principle of relevance. This principle suggests that speakers aim to provide information that is relevant to the listener's cognitive context, and implicatures play a crucial role in achieving this goal.