Discuss the concept of implicature in relation to conversational implicature understanding.

Philosophy Pragmatics Questions Medium



19 Short 80 Medium 47 Long Answer Questions Question Index

Discuss the concept of implicature in relation to conversational implicature understanding.

Implicature is a concept in pragmatics that refers to the meaning conveyed indirectly or implicitly in a conversation. It is a form of inference that goes beyond the literal meaning of the words used. Conversational implicature, on the other hand, specifically focuses on the implicatures that arise during a conversation.

Conversational implicature understanding involves recognizing and interpreting the implied meaning behind the speaker's words, rather than relying solely on the literal meaning. It requires the listener to make inferences based on the context, shared knowledge, and the speaker's intentions.

Grice's Cooperative Principle is a fundamental principle in understanding conversational implicature. According to Grice, in a conversation, participants are expected to cooperate and contribute relevant and truthful information. However, this principle also allows for implicatures to be generated when the speaker violates one of the four maxims of conversation: quantity, quality, relation, and manner.

For example, if someone asks, "Do you have any plans for the weekend?" and the listener responds, "I have a lot of work to do," the implicature is that the listener does not have any plans for the weekend. The implicature is derived from the violation of the maxim of quantity, as the listener provides more information than necessary.

Conversational implicatures can also be derived from the context, such as shared knowledge or assumptions about the speaker's intentions. For instance, if someone says, "I saw John at the party yesterday, and he was drinking a lot," the implicature could be that John was behaving irresponsibly or perhaps even drunk. This implicature is based on the shared knowledge that excessive drinking is generally considered irresponsible behavior.

In conclusion, implicature is a crucial aspect of conversational implicature understanding. It involves recognizing and interpreting the implied meaning behind the speaker's words, which often goes beyond the literal meaning. By considering the context, shared knowledge, and the speaker's intentions, listeners can derive implicatures and gain a deeper understanding of the conversation.