Philosophy Pragmatics Questions Long
In Bach and Harnish's pragmatics, the concept of implicature plays a crucial role in understanding how meaning is conveyed in communication beyond the literal interpretation of words. Implicature refers to the additional meaning that is implied or inferred by the speaker, even though it may not be explicitly stated.
According to Bach and Harnish, implicatures arise from the cooperative principle, which is a fundamental principle of communication. The cooperative principle suggests that in a conversation, participants are expected to contribute information that is relevant, truthful, and clear. However, implicatures allow speakers to go beyond the literal meaning of their words and convey additional information that is contextually implied.
There are two types of implicatures identified by Bach and Harnish: conventional implicatures and conversational implicatures. Conventional implicatures are derived from specific linguistic conventions or rules, where certain words or phrases carry additional meaning. For example, when someone says, "John is a bachelor," the conventional implicature is that John is unmarried.
Conversational implicatures, on the other hand, are derived from the context of the conversation and the cooperative principle. These implicatures are not explicitly stated but are inferred by the listener based on the speaker's intention and the context of the utterance. Grice's maxims, which are principles of conversation, play a significant role in understanding conversational implicatures. The maxims include the maxim of quantity (providing enough information), quality (being truthful), relation (being relevant), and manner (being clear and concise).
For example, if someone asks, "Do you have any plans for the weekend?" and the response is, "I have a lot of work to do," the conversational implicature is that the person does not have any plans for the weekend. This implicature is derived from the maxim of quantity, as the response does not provide any additional information about potential plans.
Implicatures are important in communication as they allow speakers to convey meaning indirectly, often adding nuances, politeness, or subtlety to their messages. They also enable listeners to interpret and understand the intended meaning beyond the literal words used. However, implicatures can sometimes lead to miscommunication or misunderstandings if the listener fails to infer the intended meaning accurately.
In conclusion, Bach and Harnish's pragmatics emphasize the concept of implicature as a means to understand how meaning is conveyed beyond the literal interpretation of words. Implicatures arise from the cooperative principle and can be conventional or conversational. They play a crucial role in enriching communication by allowing speakers to imply additional meaning and enabling listeners to infer the intended message.