What is moral anti-realism?

Philosophy Metaethics Questions Medium



42 Short 32 Medium 52 Long Answer Questions Question Index

What is moral anti-realism?

Moral anti-realism is a philosophical position that denies the existence of objective moral truths or facts. It argues that moral statements are not capable of being objectively true or false, and that moral judgments are merely expressions of personal preferences, emotions, or cultural conventions.

According to moral anti-realism, moral values and principles are not grounded in any external or transcendent reality, such as God or natural laws. Instead, they are subjective and relative to individual perspectives or societal norms. This means that moral judgments are not universally binding or objectively valid, but rather depend on personal or cultural beliefs and attitudes.

There are different forms of moral anti-realism, including moral subjectivism, cultural relativism, and error theory. Moral subjectivism holds that moral statements express individual attitudes or emotions, and their truth is determined by the subjective preferences of individuals. Cultural relativism argues that moral judgments are relative to specific cultures or societies, and what is considered morally right or wrong can vary across different cultural contexts. Error theory, on the other hand, claims that moral statements are systematically mistaken because they presuppose the existence of objective moral facts that do not actually exist.

Moral anti-realism challenges the idea of moral objectivity and the possibility of discovering universal moral truths. It emphasizes the role of subjectivity, cultural diversity, and individual perspectives in shaping moral judgments. Critics of moral anti-realism argue that it undermines the possibility of moral progress and the existence of moral obligations. However, proponents of moral anti-realism contend that it provides a more accurate understanding of the nature of morality and allows for greater tolerance and respect for diverse moral viewpoints.