Explain the argument from desire as evidence for the existence of God.

Philosophy Existence Of God Questions Medium



80 Short 38 Medium 30 Long Answer Questions Question Index

Explain the argument from desire as evidence for the existence of God.

The argument from desire is a philosophical argument that suggests that the existence of human desires and longings for something beyond the physical world can be seen as evidence for the existence of God. This argument was popularized by C.S. Lewis, a renowned Christian apologist.

According to the argument from desire, humans possess innate desires and longings that cannot be fully satisfied by anything within the natural world. These desires can include a longing for ultimate meaning, purpose, love, beauty, and transcendence. While individuals may find temporary satisfaction in various worldly pursuits, there remains a deep-seated longing for something more profound and transcendent.

Proponents of this argument argue that these desires and longings are not simply the result of societal conditioning or personal preferences, but rather reflect a deeper reality. They suggest that these desires point towards the existence of a higher being, namely God, who is the ultimate source and fulfillment of these innate human longings.

The argument from desire posits that if there is no God, then these desires would be ultimately meaningless and purposeless. However, the fact that these desires exist and persist in human beings throughout history suggests that there must be an object that can fulfill them. This object is believed to be God, who is seen as the ultimate source of meaning, purpose, and fulfillment.

Critics of the argument from desire argue that these longings can be explained by naturalistic or psychological factors, such as evolutionary processes or human imagination. They contend that the existence of desires does not necessarily imply the existence of God.

In conclusion, the argument from desire posits that the existence of innate human desires and longings for something beyond the physical world can be seen as evidence for the existence of God. It suggests that these desires point towards a deeper reality and the need for a higher being to fulfill them. However, this argument remains a matter of philosophical debate and is subject to various criticisms and counterarguments.